chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
Hi everyone!
I'm trying to figure out how to implement NASA's chlor_a algorithm in R for MODISAqua, SeaWiFS, and VIIRSSNPP. The OCx part of it has been no problem, but I'm having trouble finding which wavebands and coefficients to use for the Hu color index algorithm. I've been looking through the 3 sources below and gathering bits and pieces of information, but it would be nice to have a full table of sensorspecific wavebands and optimized coefficients.
NASA chlor_a algorithms
https://oceancolor.gsfc.nasa.gov/atbd/chlor_a/
Hu et al. (2012)
Chlorophylla algorithms for oligotrophic oceans: A novel approach based on three?band reflectance difference
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2011JC007395
Hu et al. (2019)
Improving Satellite Global Chlorophylla Data Products Through Algorithm Refinement and Data Recovery
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331098463_Improving_Satellite_Global_Chlorophyll_a_Data_Products_Through_Algorithm_Refinement_and_Data_Recovery
Can anyone point me in the right direction?
Thanks!
Stephanie
I'm trying to figure out how to implement NASA's chlor_a algorithm in R for MODISAqua, SeaWiFS, and VIIRSSNPP. The OCx part of it has been no problem, but I'm having trouble finding which wavebands and coefficients to use for the Hu color index algorithm. I've been looking through the 3 sources below and gathering bits and pieces of information, but it would be nice to have a full table of sensorspecific wavebands and optimized coefficients.
NASA chlor_a algorithms
https://oceancolor.gsfc.nasa.gov/atbd/chlor_a/
Hu et al. (2012)
Chlorophylla algorithms for oligotrophic oceans: A novel approach based on three?band reflectance difference
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2011JC007395
Hu et al. (2019)
Improving Satellite Global Chlorophylla Data Products Through Algorithm Refinement and Data Recovery
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331098463_Improving_Satellite_Global_Chlorophyll_a_Data_Products_Through_Algorithm_Refinement_and_Data_Recovery
Can anyone point me in the right direction?
Thanks!
Stephanie
Tags:
chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
The definitive reference for details of algorithms used by
Building
l2gen
is the OCSSW source ($OCSSWROOT/ocssw_src/src/l2gen/get_chl.c
). Many of the coefficients used by l2gen
come from sensorspecific parameter files so it is often easier if you can build l2gen
from source locally and add some print statements. If you have access to macOS or linux you can install the current source from the SeaDAS 8 GUI. I think the instructions for installing the OCSSW software manually are outdated, but that may not matter for the Hu algorithm.Building
l2gen
should be straightforward if you can arrange to use one of the OS versions used by NASA, e.g., in a VM. Newer linux versions have removed some functions from glibc
so the 3rd party sources won't build.
 User Services
 Posts: 1381
 Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2019 6:15 pm America/New_York
chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
Stephanie,
The Hu CI does not have sensor specific coefficients. The first reference you list identifies the current coefficients (and bands) to use for the OCx alogrithms.
Coincidentally, I was just fiddling around with an analysis and wanted to apply the OCx/Hu algorithms to some insitu data...I used Python, but should be easy enough to translate to R. Since you have OCx under control, here's what you can do for Hu and "OCI" (the blending we do operationally for our chlor_a product). (The functions below are based on the code George referenced.)
Hu from the 2019 paper (the coefficients differ from the 2012 paper, but otherwise it's the same):
To blend the OCx and Hu. This uses the 2019 paper as well, but with a lower max threshold value because the Hu algorithm with the 2019 coefficients doesn't produce a value above about 0.37 mg/m3. To mimic what we do operationally (until we reprocess), set
The OCx coefficients for the reprocessing will also change to those from the O'Reilly and Werdell (2019) paper:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2019.04.021
Hope this helps.
Sean
The Hu CI does not have sensor specific coefficients. The first reference you list identifies the current coefficients (and bands) to use for the OCx alogrithms.
Coincidentally, I was just fiddling around with an analysis and wanted to apply the OCx/Hu algorithms to some insitu data...I used Python, but should be easy enough to translate to R. Since you have OCx under control, here's what you can do for Hu and "OCI" (the blending we do operationally for our chlor_a product). (The functions below are based on the code George referenced.)
Hu from the 2019 paper (the coefficients differ from the 2012 paper, but otherwise it's the same):
def hu(rrs443,rrs555,rrs670):
w = np.array([443., 555., 670.])
a = np.array([0.4287, 230.47])
#For the 2012 version use:
# a = np.array([0.4909, 191.6590])
chl = np.NaN
ci = np.min([rrs555  (rrs443 + (w[1]  w[0]) / (w[2]  w[0])*(rrs670  rrs443)), 0.0]);
if ci <= 0.0:
chl = np.power(10.0,(a[0] + a[1] * ci))
return chl
To blend the OCx and Hu. This uses the 2019 paper as well, but with a lower max threshold value because the Hu algorithm with the 2019 coefficients doesn't produce a value above about 0.37 mg/m3. To mimic what we do operationally (until we reprocess), set
t1=0.15; t2=0.20
:def oci(hu,ocx):
t1 = 0.25
t2 = 0.35
chl = np.NaN
if ~np.isnan(hu):
if (hu <= t1):
chl = hu
else:
if (hu >= t2):
chl = ocx
else:
chl = hu * (t2  hu) / (t2  t1) + ocx * (hu  t1) / (t2  t1);
else:
chl = ocx
return chl
The OCx coefficients for the reprocessing will also change to those from the O'Reilly and Werdell (2019) paper:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2019.04.021
Hope this helps.
Sean
Re: chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
Thanks for your help! That clears up my question about the coefficients, but I'm still a little unclear about the nonSeaWiFS wavebands used in the algorithm:
The chlor_a description page says the algorithm uses the instrumentspecific wavebands closest to 443, 555, and 670... so for MODIS this should be 443, 555, 667, and for VIIRS 443, 551, 671.
... but I've read the algorithm uses MODIS 547 instead... is this true, and is it for consistency with the OCx algorithm?
Also I've seen mentions in those papers of the nonSeaWiFS green bands (MODIS 547 and VIIRS 551) being shifted to 555nm using results from regressions with NOMAD data, but the details don't appear to be in the paper, and I didn't see any mention of them doing the same with the red bands...
... Are the MODIS and VIIRS bands shifted to 555nm and 670nm, and if so, what factor is being used?
Thanks!
Steph
The chlor_a description page says the algorithm uses the instrumentspecific wavebands closest to 443, 555, and 670... so for MODIS this should be 443, 555, 667, and for VIIRS 443, 551, 671.
... but I've read the algorithm uses MODIS 547 instead... is this true, and is it for consistency with the OCx algorithm?
Also I've seen mentions in those papers of the nonSeaWiFS green bands (MODIS 547 and VIIRS 551) being shifted to 555nm using results from regressions with NOMAD data, but the details don't appear to be in the paper, and I didn't see any mention of them doing the same with the red bands...
... Are the MODIS and VIIRS bands shifted to 555nm and 670nm, and if so, what factor is being used?
Thanks!
Steph

 User Services
 Posts: 1381
 Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2019 6:15 pm America/New_York
Re: chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
The MODIS "ocean" band closest to the SeaWiFS 555nm band is 547nm (which was originally defined as 551nm, but turned out to be 547nm, so we stopped calling it 551nm. The SNPPVIIRS band is 551nm, but the NOAA20VIIRS band is 556nm. Clear as mud.). The MODIS 555nm band is a "land" band and has quite a wide spectral bandpass. It also has a lower SNR than the 547nm "ocean" band.
Since the impact of such a small shift in wavelength from 547 to 555nm can be rather large (810% in clear waters) ,there is a conversion factor applied to the Rrs from the non555nm bands to approximate Rrs at 555nm. Yes, it was derived from the NOMAD dataset, but I don't think this method was ever published. We don't exactly hide it, though I'll admit it's not exactly obvious where to find it...the function to derive this conversion factor can be found here:
https://oceancolor.sci.gsfc.nasa.gov/do ... ource.html. It's simple enough that you should have no trouble converting it to R.
The difference in the Rrs for the red bands is *much* smaller and so a similar adjustment was not derived for the 670nmish bands.
Regards,
Sean
Since the impact of such a small shift in wavelength from 547 to 555nm can be rather large (810% in clear waters) ,there is a conversion factor applied to the Rrs from the non555nm bands to approximate Rrs at 555nm. Yes, it was derived from the NOMAD dataset, but I don't think this method was ever published. We don't exactly hide it, though I'll admit it's not exactly obvious where to find it...the function to derive this conversion factor can be found here:
https://oceancolor.sci.gsfc.nasa.gov/do ... ource.html. It's simple enough that you should have no trouble converting it to R.
The difference in the Rrs for the red bands is *much* smaller and so a similar adjustment was not derived for the 670nmish bands.
Regards,
Sean
Re: chlor_a Hu color index wavebands and coefficients
Awesome! I think that answers all my questions about it. In the future it would be good to have this info available on the chlor_a description page (formula for the conversion of the color index to chlorophyll and the current coefficients in use, the blending formula, and the link to the conv_rrs_to_555 function for different green wavebands).
Thanks for all your help!
Thanks for all your help!